dolphage wrote:Mikey,
First off, they might very well clean up Skorenzy´s character and make him a loveable, gentle giant in the project. As is the custom...
Were you this upset when Denzel Washington played Rubin "Huricane" Carter like he was some kind of hero when in fact he was a hardened, violent criminal (guilty or not guilty of the murders he was sentenced for)?
Hmmm I think 'upset' isn't the word I'd choose so much as 'wary'; the Nazis carry so much baggage and did so much harm that it's very hard, almost impossible, to do the subject justice in a two hour movie. I'm really wracking my mind for movies which feature the German forces in World War 2 in a realistic manner AND which show the actual heroism many of them displayed. I'm coming up with James Mason in 'The Desert Fox' and the more recent 'Stalingrad' and that's about it.
Where a Skorzeny movie differs is that 'Stalingrad' was about the Wehrmacht's Sixth Army under Paulus and Rommel was notably apolitical if not hostile to the Nazis (he committed suicide after being linked to the von Stauffenberg revolt). The SS were *not* a normal army, they were a political force deeply steeped in Nazism and that's utterly inescapable if the movie is to be any more than a name-check for Skorzeny. His two most famous activities? Whisking Mussolini away from justice and helping crush the 1944 revolution which almost overthrew Hitler. Propping up fascist governments doesn't make for audience pleasing film making.
After that, you've got movies like the awesome 'Downfall' which starts off with a remarkable portrayal of Hitler choosing a new secretary. When she screws up her interview you expect him to rant and rage, but he's surprisingly kindly. That was a very clever trick by the filmmakers to build complexity into our view of Hitler which has become something of a cartoon thanks to so many actors putting their spin on the role. It's only after the film has shown that Hitler was, after-all, human you see the collapse into madness and it makes for an even more powerful story.
Brilliant movie.
dolphage wrote:Secondly, audiences are suposedly smart enough these days to be exposed to more complicated personal motives than "good" and "evil", in movies. Antagonists are routinely given some redeeming features to make them more beleivable. They no longer have to wear black and laugh maniacally to be the bad guy. So you CAN create a "good guy" character who is quite flawed.
I agree with you there (although I'm not so sure audiences are as smart as you'd like to think - 'The Da Vinci Code' being the classic example of a whole lot of crap that's been believed by millions). And then there was uproar in the UK when 'U571' effectively turned all of the Bletchley Park code breaking into an American adventure. The movies can produce a very lop-sided view of history, and sadly it's that view which tends to stick amongst the public.
dolphage wrote:I put my money on "cleaning him up " and making him a very likeable and politically correct character, because that´s the usual way to go.
Which risks becoming an apologist for Skorzeny. Like I said, the only way I can see this being anything other than wildly controversial and condemned to oblivion, would be for an elderly Skorzeny at the time of his denazification recounting his stories and recanting his views.
Now it's worth saying that Skorzeny, although charged with war crimes, was discharged on all counts (and they were extremely minor charges regarding wearing enemy uniforms - something the Allies had also done) and AFAIK he has never been connected to any of the atrocities committed by his regiment. He's somewhere in the league of Werhner von Braun rather than Amon Goethe or Eichmann.
But if I was involved in this movie in any way I would spend a LOT of time preparing the public relations assault that will be needed confront the inevitable 'Go see this, an Aryan superhero' publicity it will get on the far right bulletin boards across Europe. The movie mustn't become a recruiting tool for the modern day fascists and the makers must have a good response to those who want to make it so.
M.